Skip to content
Open
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
39 changes: 39 additions & 0 deletions pr-analysis-16124.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
# PR #16124: Workflow Design Impact Analysis

## Affected Workflows
- **lint-development**: This workflow is impacted because the PR introduces a new lint implementation in `clippy_lints/src/methods/unnecessary_fold.rs`, which involves declaring the lint, implementing the `check` function for detecting unnecessary `fold` calls with specific operators (Add, Mul, etc.), and integrating it into the methods module's pass (implied by registration in `mod.rs`). Additionally, new UI tests are added, and a minor utility clean-up in `clippy_utils`. This aligns with the workflow's purpose of developing and integrating new lints. Justification: Matches relevant_files like `clippy_lints/src/`, `tests/ui/`, and use of standard lint patterns.

- **testing**: Impacted by the addition of new UI test files (`tests/ui/unnecessary_fold.rs`, `.stderr`, `.fixed`), which validate the lint's behavior, diagnostics, and fix applicability. These tests will be executed as part of the UI test suite in `compile-test.rs`. Justification: Direct changes to `tests/ui/`, a key component.

- **cargo-clippy**: The new lint is now part of `clippy_lints`, so `cargo clippy` will run it on projects, potentially emitting new diagnostics. Minor change in `clippy_utils` affects shared utilities. Justification: Changed files include `clippy_lints/src/` and `clippy_utils/src/`, listed in relevant_files.

- **clippy-driver**: Similar to cargo-clippy, the driver now includes the new lint pass in its pipeline. Justification: Same relevant_files match.

No other workflows are affected, as their key files and entry points are unchanged.

## lint-development Analysis
### Summary of design changes
The PR implements a new lint following the established design without altering components, sequences, or tools. The lint is a late pass analyzing HIR expressions for `fold` calls with initial values like 0/1 and binary ops, suggesting replacements like `sum()` or `product()`. It uses existing utilities (e.g., `span_lint_and_sugg`, `snippet_with_applicability`, `peel_blocks`) and handles edge cases like turbofish needs. The design's scaffolding (via `cargo dev new_lint`) likely generated the skeleton, added `mod` to `methods/mod.rs`, and required manual addition of the `check` call in the module's pass function. Update_lints would incorporate it into global registration. No new steps added; benefits include better idiomatic code detection in iterator chains. Implications: Slightly increases compilation time for analysis but improves user experience.

No mermaid diagrams require updates, as the high-level scaffolding and integration sequences remain identical. The new lint is seamlessly added via existing "extend lint passes" and registration mechanisms.

## testing Analysis
### Summary of design changes
No changes to the testing design; the PR simply adds new test cases to the existing UI test infrastructure. The files provide examples of `fold` usage triggering the lint, with expected output matching the diagnostic message and suggestion. This ensures the lint works correctly across scenarios (e.g., with/without turbofish, different ops). When running `cargo test`, `compile-test.rs` will process these, invoking clippy-driver and verifying outputs. If fixes are applicable, `.fixed` files document them. Benefits: Validates the new lint, preventing future regressions. No modifications to dogfooding, unit tests, or other components.

No mermaid diagrams require updates. The UI tests sequence now includes these new files in the loop over test directories, but the flow is unchanged.

## cargo-clippy Analysis
### Summary of design changes
The workflow design is unaffected. The new lint enhances the analysis capabilities available when users run `cargo clippy`, detecting more patterns in user code. The minor `clippy_utils` clean-up improves internal reliability (better doc and removes dead code in `expr_use_ctxt`, used for borrow/use analysis in some lints). No changes to command-line handling, config, or driver invocation.

No mermaid diagrams require updates.

## clippy-driver Analysis
### Summary of design changes
Similar to cargo-clippy, no design alterations. The driver now registers and executes the additional `unnecessary_fold` pass during late linting phases, using the updated lint store from `declared_lints`. The utils change is incidental and does not impact the core driver logic in `src/driver.rs`.

No mermaid diagrams require updates.

## Conclusion
This PR primarily extends Clippy's linting capabilities via the lint-development and testing workflows without impacting the documented designs of any workflows. No updates to `.exp` design documents or diagrams are necessary. The changes maintain consistency with existing patterns and can be run immediately after `cargo dev update_lints` (if not already) to fully integrate.