diff --git a/pr-analysis-16124.md b/pr-analysis-16124.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000000..a35fece0bdad --- /dev/null +++ b/pr-analysis-16124.md @@ -0,0 +1,39 @@ +# PR #16124: Workflow Design Impact Analysis + +## Affected Workflows +- **lint-development**: This workflow is impacted because the PR introduces a new lint implementation in `clippy_lints/src/methods/unnecessary_fold.rs`, which involves declaring the lint, implementing the `check` function for detecting unnecessary `fold` calls with specific operators (Add, Mul, etc.), and integrating it into the methods module's pass (implied by registration in `mod.rs`). Additionally, new UI tests are added, and a minor utility clean-up in `clippy_utils`. This aligns with the workflow's purpose of developing and integrating new lints. Justification: Matches relevant_files like `clippy_lints/src/`, `tests/ui/`, and use of standard lint patterns. + +- **testing**: Impacted by the addition of new UI test files (`tests/ui/unnecessary_fold.rs`, `.stderr`, `.fixed`), which validate the lint's behavior, diagnostics, and fix applicability. These tests will be executed as part of the UI test suite in `compile-test.rs`. Justification: Direct changes to `tests/ui/`, a key component. + +- **cargo-clippy**: The new lint is now part of `clippy_lints`, so `cargo clippy` will run it on projects, potentially emitting new diagnostics. Minor change in `clippy_utils` affects shared utilities. Justification: Changed files include `clippy_lints/src/` and `clippy_utils/src/`, listed in relevant_files. + +- **clippy-driver**: Similar to cargo-clippy, the driver now includes the new lint pass in its pipeline. Justification: Same relevant_files match. + +No other workflows are affected, as their key files and entry points are unchanged. + +## lint-development Analysis +### Summary of design changes +The PR implements a new lint following the established design without altering components, sequences, or tools. The lint is a late pass analyzing HIR expressions for `fold` calls with initial values like 0/1 and binary ops, suggesting replacements like `sum()` or `product()`. It uses existing utilities (e.g., `span_lint_and_sugg`, `snippet_with_applicability`, `peel_blocks`) and handles edge cases like turbofish needs. The design's scaffolding (via `cargo dev new_lint`) likely generated the skeleton, added `mod` to `methods/mod.rs`, and required manual addition of the `check` call in the module's pass function. Update_lints would incorporate it into global registration. No new steps added; benefits include better idiomatic code detection in iterator chains. Implications: Slightly increases compilation time for analysis but improves user experience. + +No mermaid diagrams require updates, as the high-level scaffolding and integration sequences remain identical. The new lint is seamlessly added via existing "extend lint passes" and registration mechanisms. + +## testing Analysis +### Summary of design changes +No changes to the testing design; the PR simply adds new test cases to the existing UI test infrastructure. The files provide examples of `fold` usage triggering the lint, with expected output matching the diagnostic message and suggestion. This ensures the lint works correctly across scenarios (e.g., with/without turbofish, different ops). When running `cargo test`, `compile-test.rs` will process these, invoking clippy-driver and verifying outputs. If fixes are applicable, `.fixed` files document them. Benefits: Validates the new lint, preventing future regressions. No modifications to dogfooding, unit tests, or other components. + +No mermaid diagrams require updates. The UI tests sequence now includes these new files in the loop over test directories, but the flow is unchanged. + +## cargo-clippy Analysis +### Summary of design changes +The workflow design is unaffected. The new lint enhances the analysis capabilities available when users run `cargo clippy`, detecting more patterns in user code. The minor `clippy_utils` clean-up improves internal reliability (better doc and removes dead code in `expr_use_ctxt`, used for borrow/use analysis in some lints). No changes to command-line handling, config, or driver invocation. + +No mermaid diagrams require updates. + +## clippy-driver Analysis +### Summary of design changes +Similar to cargo-clippy, no design alterations. The driver now registers and executes the additional `unnecessary_fold` pass during late linting phases, using the updated lint store from `declared_lints`. The utils change is incidental and does not impact the core driver logic in `src/driver.rs`. + +No mermaid diagrams require updates. + +## Conclusion +This PR primarily extends Clippy's linting capabilities via the lint-development and testing workflows without impacting the documented designs of any workflows. No updates to `.exp` design documents or diagrams are necessary. The changes maintain consistency with existing patterns and can be run immediately after `cargo dev update_lints` (if not already) to fully integrate. \ No newline at end of file