Unknown panel request data

[garbled1]

I am attempting to understand how to decode two of the panel commands. Please run the test by executing: python -m pybalboa <spa_ip> from inside the base of the git repo. This runs a basic test. Then paste the data in this section:

Sending unknown commands
Got msg: 7e1a0abf2464dc140042503230303047310451800c6b010a0200f97e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000368053800020000080c01000000000000012068000000437e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000368053800020000080c01000000000000012068000000437e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000368053800020000080c01000000000000012068000000437e
Got msg: 7e0e0abf25120432635068290341197e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000368053800020000080c01000000000000012068000000437e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000368053800020000080c01000000000000012068000000437e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000368053800020000080c01000000000000012068000000437e
Please add this section to issue:

Hopefully if I get enough of them, I can figure out how to decode those sections. I think I more or less understand them, but it's not 100%.

Also, when posting, anything you can provide about your spa, like the model, voltage, panel model if known, etc etc would be nice.

[fabltd]

Hi Tim

Here you go. - BTW the temp is reading wrong. Also it crashed.

******* Testing CRC **********
Expected CRC=0x77 got 0x77
Expected CRC=0x6 got 0x6
******** Testing basic commands **********
Asking for base config
7e1e0abf94021480001527729bf80000000000000000001527ffff729bf8287e
Got msg: 7e1e0abf94021480001527729bf80000000000000000001527ffff729bf8287e
Mac Addr: 0:15:27:72:9b:f8
Pump Array: [1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Light Array: [1, 0]
Asking for panel config
7e0b0abf2e1500019000003c7e
Got msg: 7e0b0abf2e1500019000003c7e
Pump Array: [1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0]
Light Array: [1, 0]
Aux Array: [0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Blower: 0
Mister: 0
******** Testing engine ***********
7e0b0abf2e1500019000003c7e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
Config is loaded:
Pump Array: [1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0]
Light Array: [1, 0]
Aux Array: [0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Blower: 0
Mister: 0
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 data as of 1578265262.164663
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
New data as of 1578265263.066945
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
New data as of 1578265264.23464
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
New data as of 1578265265.2164009
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
New data as of 1578265266.137574
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
New data as of 1578265267.235327
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
New data as of 1578265267.835741
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
New data as of 1578265269.110508
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
New data as of 1578265269.949491
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
7e20ffaf1300004e170000004f500b0c0000020000000000004e0000005a0000767e
New data as of 1578265270.8451
Current Temp: 25.555555555555557
Tempscale: C
Set Temp: 25.555555555555557
Heat Mode: 0
Heat State: 0
Temp Range: 1
Pump Status: [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: 0
Aux Status: [0, 0]

Spa read failed: 0 bytes read on a total of 2 expected bytes
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "pybalboa/balboa.py", line 379, in read_one_message
header = await self.reader.readexactly(2)
File "/Applications/Xcode.app/Contents/Developer/Library/Frameworks/Python3.framework/Versions/3.7/lib/python3.7/asyncio/streams.py", line 677, in readexactly
raise IncompleteReadError(incomplete, n)
asyncio.streams.IncompleteReadError: 0 bytes read on a total of 2 expected bytes
(demo) %

[garbled1]

Can you tell me what the temp was when you ran the test? Just trying to figure out what the math would be.

Thank you!

[fabltd]

Hi I think you need to x2. Should be 39 c JT On 8 Jan 2020, at 22:05, Tim Rightnour <notifications@github.com> wrote:  Can you tell me what the temp was when you ran the test? Just trying to figure out what the math would be. Thank you! — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#1?email_source=notifications&email_token=ABGCGRT6DS2WUTFHIIGXJUTQ4ZEZPA5CNFSM4J6G6LB2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEIOEWNI#issuecomment-572279605>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABGCGRV6M2TTESEX7XZ43ZLQ4ZEZPANCNFSM4J6G6LBQ> .

[dcwyzant]

Assuming you still want these since the issue is open

Sending unknown commands
Got msg: 7e1a0abf2464c913004d51425035303120010403daed01060400357e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000066120900005a000a04010000000000000000660000003d7e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000066120900005a000a04010000000000000000660000003d7e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000066120900005a000a04010000000000000000660000003d7e
Got msg: 7e0e0abf25040132633c68080341c07e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000066120900005a000a04010000000000000000660000003d7e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000066120900005a000a04010000000000000000660000003d7e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000066120900005a000a04010000000000000000660000003d7e
Please add this section to issue:

[vincedarley]

Here you go, for my Spa (wish I'd seen this earlier - I've been building the homebridge-balboa-spa plugin).

******** Testing basic commands **********
Asking for base config
Got msg: 7e1e0abf940214800015273f9b950000000000000000001527ffff3f9b951d7e
Mac Addr: 0:15:27:3f:9b:95
Pump Array: [1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Light Array: [1, 0]
Asking for panel config
Got msg: 7e0b0abf2e1a0001900000ac7e
Pump Array: [1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0]
Light Array: [1, 0]
Aux Array: [0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Blower: 0
Mister: 0
Sending unknown commands
Got msg: 7e1a0abf2464e124004d5334304520202001c3479636030a4400197e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf1300004c140000000306070c0100020000000000004c0000003a7e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf1300004c140000000306070c0100020000000000004c0000003a7e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf1300004c140000000306070c0100020000000000004c0000003a7e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf1300004c140000000306070c0100020000000000004c0000003a7e
Got msg: 7e0e0abf25050132635068610741287e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf1300004c140000000306070c0100020000000000004c0000003a7e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf1300004c140000000306070c0100020000000000004c0000003a7e
Please add this section to issue:
#1
******** Testing engine ***********
Config is loaded:
Pump Array: [1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0]
Light Array: [1, 0]
Aux Array: [0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Blower: 0
Mister: 0

New data as of 1589655637.412055
Current Temp: 38.0
Tempscale: Celcius
Set Temp: 38.0
Heat Mode: Ready
Heat State: Off
Temp Range: High
Pump Status: [1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Circulation Pump: On
Light Status: [0, 0]
Mister Status: None
Aux Status: [0, 0]
Blower Status: None
Spa Time: 20:0 12h
Filter Mode: Cycle 1

(The config looks correct to me: 1 light, 3 pumps, no mister or blower)

[vincedarley]

Although above, pump1 & 2 are 2-speed pumps, and pump 3 is only 1-speed. So that part of the status hasn't been discovered it seems.

[garbled1]

So IIRC, the pumps don't report as having a speed capability, but when you cycle them, they report current speed. In theory the 1 speed would never cycle into high? I don't actually have a 1 speed pump... Thanks for your assist! Hopefully I can decode these messages.. I think I'm close.

[vincent0794]

Actually I'm pretty sure the 2-bits per pump reported here do encode the speeds. My 3 pumps report 0x1a which corresponds to 00011010 - i.e. pump 1 is 2 speed, pump 2 is 2 speed and pump 3 is 1 speed. (Which is correct).

[aci-drain]

Hi, also sending my output:

******* Testing CRC **********
Expected CRC=0x77 got 0x77
Expected CRC=0x6 got 0x6
******** Testing basic commands **********
Asking for base config
Got msg: 7e1e0abf94020a800015271a51690000000000000000001527ffff1a5169aa7e
Mac Addr: 0:15:27:1a:51:69
Pump Array: [1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0]
Light Array: [1, 0]
Asking for panel config
Got msg: 7e0b0abf2e050001910000c97e
Pump Array: [1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Light Array: [1, 0]
Aux Array: [0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Blower: 1
Mister: 0
Sending unknown commands
Got msg: 7e1a0abf2464e11400425032313030473111ebce9fd8030a1600d77e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000049100f00000306032c0a00020000000000004a000000c07e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000049100f00000306032c0a00020000000000004a000000c07e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000049100f00000306032c0a00020000000000004a000000c07e
Got msg: 7e0e0abf25121132635068610341a67e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000049100f00000306032c0a00020000000000004a000000c07e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000049100f00000306032c0a00020000000000004a000000c07e
Got msg: 7e1dffaf13000049100f00000306032c0a00020000000000004a000000c07e
Please add this section to issue:
#1
******** Testing engine ***********
Config is loaded:
Pump Array: [1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0]
Light Array: [1, 0]
Aux Array: [0, 0]
Circulation Pump: 1
Blower: 1
Mister: 0

New data as of 1590329646.5673845
Current Temp: 36.5
Tempscale: Celcius
Set Temp: 37.0
Heat Mode: Ready
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/usr/lib/python3.7/runpy.py", line 193, in _run_module_as_main
"main", mod_spec)
File "/usr/lib/python3.7/runpy.py", line 85, in _run_code
exec(code, run_globals)
File "/home/alexandervollmer/.local/lib/python3.7/site-packages/pybalboa/main.py", line 161, in
asyncio.run(mini_engine(sys.argv[1]))
File "/usr/lib/python3.7/asyncio/runners.py", line 43, in run
return loop.run_until_complete(main)
File "/usr/lib/python3.7/asyncio/base_events.py", line 584, in run_until_complete
return future.result()
File "/home/alexandervollmer/.local/lib/python3.7/site-packages/pybalboa/main.py", line 109, in mini_engine
print("Heat State: {0}".format(spa.get_heatstate(True)))
File "/home/alexandervollmer/.local/lib/python3.7/site-packages/pybalboa/balboa.py", line 855, in get_heatstate
return text_switch[self.heatstate]
IndexError: list index out of range

[garbled1]

Huh.. thats.. really odd. your heat state returned something crazy. Normally that's an on/off.. I wouldn't expect it to be something other than those two... Does your spa have multiple heat states other than just ON/OFF ? Or maybe something else is being encoded there that I don't understand.

[garbled1]

OK.. @vincedarley it looks like the nrofpumps in the config resp is a bit of a lie? or maybe I parse that wrong and it's an int not a bitmask. That's interesting.. then on your panel config... ok.. maybe I have a fix for this..

[aci-drain]

I don’t think so. It should be just on or off. The spa is located in Germany. Maybe some location/language problems? Can I do some further debugging?